Origin and Establishment of the League of Nations

By the end of the First World War, Europe was in ruins, facing economic hardship and political turmoil. The conflict had escalated across the continent, with Austria and Germany fighting against Bosnia, Britain, France, and Russia. As the Allied and Central Powers emerged from the war in 1918, there was a profound desire for peace and a commitment to finding a lasting solution to prevent future catastrophes. In light of this urgency, the idea of an international organization was born, aimed at maintaining peace and resolving conflicts through diplomacy. This vision ultimately led to the creation of the League of Nations.

President Woodrow Wilson and the League

President Woodrow Wilson of the United States is often seen as the ‘father’ of the League of Nations. In a message to Congress on January 22, 1917, just before the U.S. entered the war, he advocated establishing an international organization dedicated to maintaining world peace. A year later, on January 8, 1918, he introduced his famous Fourteen Points, with the last point calling for “a general association of nations must be formed under specific covenants to afford guarantees of political independence and territorial integrity.”

A committee of 14, which Wilson presided over, prepared the draft of the League’s covenant. His modified version was accepted at the conference on April 28, 1919, and the covenant was included in all peace treaties, notably the Treaty of Versailles. Thus, Wilson’s vision for an effective international organization began to take shape. However, despite these contributions, the United States never became a member of the League, as the Senate refused to ratify the treaty.

The League and World Peace

The League of Nations was founded to uphold world peace and seek peaceful resolutions for international disputes. It was the first global organization specifically aimed at peacekeeping, characterized by permanence, standardized representation, and universal membership. Officially formed in line with the decisions made during the Paris Peace Conference in 1919, its covenant was adopted and incorporated into all treaties agreed upon in Paris, coming into existence on January 10, 1920, thus marking the official end of the war.

The League adopted a covenant, known as the League Covenant, which created an alliance of states that committed, by signing the covenant, to resolving their disputes peacefully before resorting to war. Any state that refused to submit its disputes to the League was deemed a threat to the international order and would face collective actions from other member states. This principle, called collective sanction, might involve a declaration of war against the state perceived as a threat or the implementation of economic embargoes or sanctions. Consequently, the League’s covenant established the basis for collective security and sanctions.

Objectives of the League of Nations

The League’s purposes, as detailed in its Covenant, included:

1. Promoting and maintaining international peace and cooperation.

2. Preventing wars between nations.

3. Fostering open, just, and honorable relations.

4. Enforcing international law and treaty obligations.

5. Regulating intergovernmental affairs based on legal justice.

Organs of the League of Nations

1. The General Assembly: The highest decision-making body, responsible for admitting new members.

2. The Council: Operated similarly to today’s UN Security Council, handling major decisions.

3. The Secretariat: Responsible for the day-to-day administrative tasks of the League.

4. The Permanent Court of International Justice (ICJ): Resolved legal disputes and provided advisory opinions.

Diplomatic Mechanisms and Peacekeeping Methods

To resolve international disputes, the League of Nations, used several diplomatic procedures:

1. Commission of Inquiry: Investigated incidents and disputes.

2. World Court Referrals: Cases referred to the ICJ.

3. Issuance of ceasefires or armistices.

4. Expulsion of aggressive member states.

5. Imposition of economic sanctions or embargoes.

However, by 1939, none of these mechanisms could prevent the onset of the Second World War, as major powers, including the USSR, Germany, and Italy, began to prioritize their own national interests over those of League members. This shift ultimately led to the outbreak of the Second World War in 1939.

Failures of the League of Nations

Despite its commendable goals, the League of Nations faced significant challenges:

1. Failure to Enforce Collective Security

The League of Nations did not possess the authority needed to enforce Article 10 of its Covenant, which ensured collective security for member states. It struggled to respond decisively when peace was in jeopardy.

2. Weak Response to Aggression

In 1931, when Japan invaded Manchuria, the League merely condemned the action without taking any substantial measures. Japan dismissed the League’s protests and continued its aggressive behavior.

Similarly, during the Abyssinian Crisis (1935–1936), Italy invaded Ethiopia. Although the League imposed sanctions, major powers like Britain and France undermined the effort by supplying Italy with resources like oil.

3. Inaction During the Spanish Civil War

The League remained passive during the Spanish Civil War (1936–1939), failing to prevent external involvement or mediate the conflict effectively.

4. Lack of Jurisdiction in Colonial Matters

The League had no authority over colonial territories. It failed to address injustices in regions like British-controlled Iraq and French-controlled Syria, further exposing its limitations.

5. Absence of the United States

The refusal of the U.S. Senate to ratify the Treaty of Versailles meant the League was deprived of the support of one of the most powerful nations. Wilson’s own country never joined, weakening the League’s global influence.

6. No Military Force

The League of Nations had no standing military to enforce its resolutions. It had to rely on member states to carry out sanctions or military action, which often did not happen due to conflicting interests.

7. Lack of Unity Among Members

Member states lacked cohesion and often prioritized national interest over collective goals. This disunity was evident when sanctions on Italy were undermined by other League members.

8. Rise of Dictators and Defiance of the League

The rise of fascist leaders like Mussolini in Italy and Hitler in Germany exposed the League’s impotence. These leaders defied the League, committed acts of aggression, and eventually withdrew from it altogether.

9. Failure to Prevent World War II

By the late 1930s, the League of Nations had failed in its primary mission: preventing another world war. The defiance by major powers, coupled with the League’s inability to act, led to the outbreak of World War II in 1939.

Conclusion

The League of Nations was a pioneering institution in the pursuit of global peace and collective diplomacy. It laid the foundation for future international cooperation through its structure, objectives, and ideals. However, its numerous lapses, ranging from a lack of enforcement power and internal unity to the absence of key global players, ultimately rendered it ineffective in achieving its core mission. Its legacy, though flawed, set the groundwork for the establishment of the United Nations in 1945.

ALSO READ:World War II